Modern Manual Therapy Blog - Manual Therapy, Videos, Neurodynamics, Podcasts, Research Reviews: Modern Motor Control
Showing posts with label Modern Motor Control. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Modern Motor Control. Show all posts
Photo by Jaunathan Gagnon on Unsplash

How we conceptualize our body, our joints and tissues, affects how we react to situations that involve those tissues. Our joints and tissues represent, in the minds of most laypersons, a static entity. That is, “they are what they are”. They can often be viewed as the sum of all stresses, where stresses are responsible for “wearing out” the tissues. This analysis can be misleading. How we conceptualize our tissues dictates, or at least influences, how we behave. In essence, we act out in the real world what we believe to be true about our bodies.

The “wear and tear” model of joint structure, while intuitive and rational in terms of what we know about the world (we all are well aware discontinuity of all things that exist, aside change), has some misconceptions when applied to the living adaptable system that is our body. The main misconception involves the belief that tissue wear itself is irriversable tissue degeneration. In a world where tissue wear = degeneration = pain, the body can be viewed much like a car, in that based on amount of use (ie at 200k miles) it requires a replacement.

I can't remember the reference, but I once read of a tribe whom held the belief that a human has a finite number of heart beats before death. The tribe would act in accordance to this belief, and move very slowly, avoiding any increase in heart rate. They became fragile, soft and sloth like sedentary citizens, and their king existed in a near immobile state, spoon fed and manually transported. Yes, their hearts beat slowly. But at what cost was this belief? Was what they were acting out advancing the intentions of their belief, or to their detriment?

There is mounting evidence and exposure on the tenuous link between tissue and damage, and the more we can re-conceptualize our bodies as adaptive, the less likely we are to fall in line with the aforementioned tribe, mistaking cure for disease.

Bringing this to light can be of therapeutic value in many ways. If we can change what someone believes about their condition, then we can change what they act out, which has incremental returns. The job doesn’t end with just stating information about the body being adaptable. In order for a person to make an informed decision to change how they react to their pain, they need to find this new conceptualization of an adaptable system interesting. If it isn’t interesting, then there is likely no cognitive shift in understanding, and behavior would be unlikely to change.
The idiom “Wear and Tear” (a phrase also labeled by Butler/Moseley to be a particularly “sticky” neuro-tag in is roll-off-the-tongue ease) is usually somewhere in the mind of a patient. In reality, there is tear. There is breakdown. It is completely unavoidable. What can be missed though in the patient-physio interaction is the education that tissue “learns”, changes and responds. This is part and parcel of what Butler and Moseley are bringing to the rehab table. There are too many real interactions between the immune system, thoughts and beliefs, stress and sleep, behavior etc… to view pain in a purely isolated biological tissue mechanistic sense. That is, it isn’t exactly the painful joint (or the muscle or body part) but how that body part is acting in its environment. The “how it is acting” has implications both at the tissue state, and at the individual tissue owner’s state.

I am reminded of a recent PT visit of a woman in her 80’s that had severe scoliosis and it was affecting her gait. She wasn’t coming in because of pain, as she didn’t have any. She was just concerned about the way her walk looked, and her balance. Here is a great example of wear and tear, structural changes and tissue “dysfunction” over the course of an entire life without manifesting any mentionable pain level. But when we are under the influence of pain, it is much more difficult to zoom out and look at the big picture: there exists a present reminder of pain that can consistently confirm our beliefs that something is wrong, that we are at 200k on that tissue. It is difficult to imagine the educational messages of adaptation outweighing innate messages of pain (yes pain is output, but its output circles back around to a cognitive psychological input). But part of that depends on how relieved the patient is to find out the truth about their condition (this goes back to the interest). If for months you suspected a sneaking terminal cancer, awaking in the middle of the night dreading it and imagining and feeling symptoms that confirmed this daily, and finally getting to a specialist only to find that your symptoms were, all from say a gluten allergy, imagine your relief. Its not terminal cancer! Its just an allergy! A weight is lifted…this can change.

Can we shift our views, in a similar sense, when we think about low back pain, neck pain or knee pain? Are our pains conformation of a static and irreversibly damaged tissue? Or could they be a feared cancer without any relevant diagnosis? What would lift the weight of our concerns? Part of this is education. The other part is learned through experience, when the person starts to behave differently and treat the tissue based on what they may have learned through the education. We act out what we believe (we hobble on a joint we believe to be fragile, we move carefully and slow when expecting pain, we change what we do if we are afraid that activity will cause damage, we tense up with pain, and we avoid positions and loads that our tissues have disliked in the past). These behaviors can have their place, but their protection can often quickly become unwarranted.

Back to wear and tear, lets take a metaphor. Imagine a small cabin in the forest of Alaska. In that cabin lives a particularly industrious jack-of-all trades woodsman. His goal is survival, and to survive he keeps his cabin fortified. He learns how to properly fortify his cabin based on what he experiences over the years; wet falls, heavy winters, bears in the summer clawing their way in…you might liken that cabin to your body, where its under constant surveillance of your nervouse system and brain. The tissues are constantly being monitored, and changing in small ways based on what they experience. In a simple mechanical sense, these could be stress, strain, and all things detected by “mechanoreceptors”. In an immunological sense, these could be chemical changes, cellular response, and all things “chemoreceptor”. The cabin does eventually break down over 100 years. Tissue will always eventually degenerate. But, it also gets fixed up along the way, making areas of weakness more robust, and adding support where it is most needed. In a living system, there is adaptation.

Disk degeneration, or “DDD” is a common term brought up by patients with back pain. One argument against some of the medical overemphasis on disc loading strategy is disk research is conducted in-vitro to “non-living” tissue, and doesn’t respond the same to actual living tissue. But even then, disc degeneration doesn’t necessarily have anything to do with pain (back to the woman with severe scoliosis, and all sorts of disc degeneration). There are many angles we can help address where the body is working for the bothersome tissue, not against it. This may come in the form of load management, sleep education, graded exposure to reduce sensitivity, getting stronger globally to support the painful area, increasing cardio for improved blood flow (this could be an arm bike for a person with knee pain, or a leg bike for a person with neck pain… just something to globally improve vascularity).

Not only is the term “wear and tear” misleading (as it should be more something like “wear/load, and create adaptations to best/better tolerate future wear/load”), it also isn’t strongly correlated with pain, which is almost always the primary complaint. Take knee OA for example. Researchers are now referring to this condition as “symptomatic knee OA” (and more and more conditions are allowing this discriminating preamble) because radiographic knee OA does not equate pain.

The consensus is clear that as age and OA findings have a linear relationship, which does not come as a surprise. But remember, OA does not equal pain. The Framingham Osteoarthritis Study found that 10% of people aged 63 years and over had symptomatic knee OA (pain) in the presence of radiographic changes (1). In people with severe OA, it seems about half report pain (2). Although some studies find the link of reported pain and OA severity less clear, some large scale studies (4000 subjects) finds a clear relations between the roughly 40% of persons with radiographic OA and pain (3). Even in these studies, 60% of the persons with radiographic OA did not have pain. Further, can the 40% improve? If so, their “radiographic” OA isn’t changing….

Back to the education component. A study I like to reference is a recent “JOSPT perspective for patients.” (4) The important part to get across is, the more you load the tissue doesn’t necessarily mean the worse off the tissue is. Again, the structural life of tissue is not a ticking clock that only that only counts down to zero. People that don’t jump around, load and move (sedentary individuals) have a higher chance of radiographic knee OA than recreational runners. And people that are obsessive about running (over 57 miles/week runners) only have slight more signs of usage than sedentary people! The take home point is that, to a large level, tissue adapts and becomes more robust, depending what it is introduced to and how it is introduced (ie graded VS overworked). I also like to bring up the fact that people can train themselves to run 26 miles, without their body reacting to that load with severe pain and inflammation. If a runner runs 15 miles in the first month, they may be hobbling in pain for a few weeks. If they train, running 3, 2, 5, 4, 8, 3, 3, 8, 4, 10 miles and so on, they can undergo the same “wear and tear” load, with a totally different response. The response is different not because the person is just stronger or more fit (even though that may be part) but because the body gets familiar with the jolts and pounding of running, and has time to adjust to this and not be alarmed by it. If it (the brain) isn’t alarmed, then the alarm signals (pain) are not present. I also like to reference the Moseley / Butler diagram of “twin peaks” (5). This illustrates that the alarm is going to be set at a lower threshold after injury (even though the actual tissue tolerance can be still robust, especially after proper healing time).

I like tangible examples that don’t get too deep in the physiology of pain. We don't want to move into a completely mechanistic explanation of neurophysiology to replace a mechanistic explanation of structure. There are a lot of simple examples out there that can be used to open up a conversation about the pain in question and how it relates to structure. There is growing evidence that many things influence pain, and how we understand the issue may dictate how we then interact with the world. Not only do we need to change beliefs through our rhetorical explanations, we need to disconfirm beliefs (a term used by Peter O’sullivan in his CFT workshop) in a physical, real body activity and movement sense.

There will always be cases where structure wins, where structure truly needs to be replaced, or “fixed”. Unfortunately, for the same reason we mention tissue damage doesn’t equate pain, fixing the structure doesn’t promise pain relief, and we can look to lumbar fusion outcomes to see it isn’t a cure-all to decompress and immobilize areas reported painful. Some areas respond better to "fixing" than others. We can often mistake symptoms for a disease, and be confused on the relevancy of a patient with one, or both of those variables. Either way, if we are going for conservative treatment, we need to go about it right, with the right outlook and information. This conceptualization should act as a critical foundational understanding to which the rest of the rehab experience can fall under. Following a narrative of adaptation, strength, desensitization and graded exposure, patients will have a better understanding of what physical therapy means, and their individual role in rehab from the specific irritable tissue to the global influencing factors in their lives.

-Tal Blair, DPT - via Motion Guidance blog - check out the MG Clinicians' Kit below!
Want to learn in person? Attend a #manualtherapyparty! Check out our course calendar below!

Learn more online!


Want an approach that enhances your existing evaluation and treatment? No commercial model gives you THE answer. You need an approach that blends the modern with the old school. Live cases, webinars, lectures, Q&A, hundreds of techniques and more! Check out Modern Manual Therapy!

Keeping it Eclectic...


🤔⁉ This is a Q&A from a MMT follower on social media. When watching a patient/client do a Turkish Get Up, he noticed a huge difference in AROM vs PROM unweighted cervical rotation. What's an easy and fast way to work on limited AROM when PROM is full? 😲😎

Often times in rehabilitation, we over simplify or over complicate various topics. This can be done with or without intentions. It can have beneficial or detrimental effects on transferring this information back to our clients or on to other rehabilitation professionals. Take vision in motor learning for instance. It is taken for granted that vision play a primary role in both learning as well as adapting to our environments around us. The ability to process information classical starts with visual based inputs and in support of skill building. Did you know that two different visual systems have been documented in the literature? They are referred to as the dorsal (ambient) stream and the ventral (focal) stream (Ungerleider 1982). They are understood to have different specializations and are used in different ways during daily motor processing.
        The ventral stream is used for conscious identification of objects that lie primarily in the center of the visual field. Therefore, as you are reading these words on your smart phone, the primary input is coming from the ventral system. It is responsible for the conscious perception of objects and can be manipulated by alterations in environment lighting such as dimly lit rooms or driving as night.
          The dorsal stream is believed to be used for movement control utilizing the whole visual field. Both central and peripheral. The dorsal stream operates unconsciously contributing to the fine motor control movements we perform.

        How have we figured this out? One evidence of is from the term “blindsight”. If I may just quote this area specifically from Motor Learning and Performance 5th edition by Schmidt, “Perhaps the most startling, and most convincing, evidence came from the study of two human neurological patients, TN and DB. TN had had two successive strokes, causing major neurological damage to his visual cortex, which rendered him “blind” in both eyes. After considerable study, researchers took TN to the hallway, asking him to walk down the hallway without his usual cane. Unbeknownst to TN, researchers had placed several objects in the hall around which avoided them all, even pressing himself against the wall to avoid a trash can. Patient DB, whose occipital cortex had been removed surgically because of a tumor, was also “blind” according to the traditional measures of vision. Researcher used forced-choice tests, in which DB was asked to guess where, between two locations in front of him, an object had been placed. His guesses were significantly more accurate than chance, even though he could not see the objects.”
        Taking consideration into these extraordinary situations, it got me thinking about how we might utilize understanding of the above to enhance visual information processing during rehabilitation?
          Are we giving more consideration than just having eyes open or eyes closed during activities? Should we be more focused on introducing an open environment with foreground, background, and peripheral visual field training? Especially for our athletes? Could we maximize our vision processing by putting our clients into situations that enhance the use of both their ventral and dorsal streams of visual input to increase their reaction times, up-train their feedforward mechanisms via learning and processing, and make them LESS reliant on the ventral stream?
            A couple of recently published articles by DR Grooms seems to lead us down this path. If you aren’t aware of Grooms…search him out. In my opinion, he is doing some cutting edge research regarding visual-motor processing, see how the brain potential changes as environments change, and how the body reacts to different stimuli. In his published study found here, he makes a compelling argument establishing a link “between dynamic movement mechanics, neurocognition, and visual processing regarding anterior cruciate ligament injury adaptations and injury risk.”  
            Perhaps utilizing training tools to not just focus on “sexy” exercises on soft balls, and jumping over objects (these have their place in specific areas of rehabilitation), but also incorporate more dorsal stream neurocognitive recognition stimulation via multiple “levels” of vision processing may improve the ability to compensate for external stimuli and/or attenuate the rapid maneuvers that depend on quick visual-motor interaction. His full explanations can be found here . The succinct answer is faster reaction times, possible increased visual processing via the dorsal vs ventral stream, and decreased visual reliance on motor skills in the autonomous phase may improve preparation for incoming perturbations while maintaining neuromuscular integrity.

Examples of the previous statement could range from basic recognition of flashes of different colors in the background while juggling; or more advanced utilizing strobe training glasses while catching a ball. Environments that facilitate more feedforward mechanisms than feedback andadding neurocognitive elements to injury prevention and rehabilitation programs may reduce motor control errors during sport when visual-spatial responsibilities are in high demand.






Eric Dinkins via Motion Guidance
Keeping it Eclectic...


This quick blog will discuss some options for early rehab utilizing visual feedback with a knee patient. This may apply to post operative ACL rehab or Total Knee rehab, or any patient needing to lock in some early-on skills such as terminal knee extension range of motion or open chain hip control.



“Physical therapists talk too much.”
This was how my professor started the presentation. The class was “Principles of Motor Learning and Motor Control” and the presentation was on feedback. After this statement, our professor then gave us a task. He asked us to go to a physical therapy gym and just close our eyes and listen. What did we hear? Who did we hear? What were they saying? He argued that in most instances you’d hear the physical therapist talking and probably talking too much.

To understand why therapists should talk less, we need to review the principles of feedback in motor learning. There is task-intrinsic feedback that the performer receives themselves through their sensory systems, and then there is augmented feedback that is additional information, usually provided verbally by the therapist (although there are other methods of providing feedback including visual and kinesthetic). In most instances, verbal feedback should be minimal in order to maximize learning and skill acquisition.

Too much feedback can overwhelm the individual. When learning a new task or exercise, a significant amount of the person’s attention is devoted to performing the task. If too much attention is devoted to interpreting verbal instructions and feedback, the individual’s ability to internally process and learn how to complete the task is impaired. Additionally, an individual may become dependent on verbal cues. In this circumstance, the performance of the task may improve, but retention and transfer to similar tasks are worse.

Why do physical therapists still tend to talk too much and provide too much instruction and feedback? We want it to seem like we are providing skilled services. We want to show this for the patient, for the insurance companies, and even for ourselves. Sometimes we fall for the trick of seeing an improvement in performance of the skill or exercise during that session, but this doesn’t necessarily transfer to improved retention of the skill later on or transfer to similar skills. Also, we feel pressure from the insurance companies to demonstrate skilled and necessary services. I remember in one of my clinical-internships writing, “PT provided 75% verbal cues throughout gait training for step length and heel strike” (or something of that nature). In retrospect, providing that much cueing while a person was walking seems absurd. Last but not least, as therapists (and humans) we have a desire to feel like we are important and needed. Intuitively, it seems that the more instructions and feedback we provide, the more we can help the patient. However, based on the research and what we’ve been taught, this isn’t the case. There are many other effective ways to use our skills and knowledge to optimally help our patients.

By limiting feedback and instructions to only the vital key components, you allow the individual to be active in learning the skill and allow internal processing and learning to occur. There are a variety of ways to limit the amount of verbal feedback and instruction you provide. Let’s briefly review a couple of the different ways to provide feedback…
  • Continuous: providing feedback the whole time. We want to avoid this for the reasons stated above.
  • Concurrent: providing feedback during the task performance. This can overwhelm the individual or the individual may become dependent on it.
Here are some ways to limit feedback and improve learning and retention:
  • Delayed: provide feedback after the trial and after a brief pause. The pause allows time for the individual to internally process any task-intrinsic feedback
  • Faded: start by providing a lot of feedback and then decrease the amount over time
  • Intermittent: provide feedback only after some trials. Examples of this are summary feedback or averaged feedback that is provided after a number of trials are completed
  • Bandwidth: provide feedback only when the amount of error falls outside a certain amount or percentage. For example, you only provide feedback if there is 5% error or greater.
  • Self-selected: the individual determines when they want feedback and can ask for it specifically
Transitional: therapist asks leading questions that help the individual internally process their mistakes and make appropriate corrections. The person can verbally describe to the therapist what they think they did wrong.

What are the characteristics of good verbal instructions, feedback, or cues? They should be short, concise, and draw attention to only the critical elements of the task or exercise. They should be limited in quantity and focused on the strategies for achieving the goal of the task. It should be timely to allow for internal processing. As Richard Magill writes, “verbal instructions should present the minimum amount of information necessary to communicate what a person needs to do to perform a skill. Providing too much information in verbal instructions can be like providing no verbal instructions at all.”

Verbal feedback and instructions are a critical aspect of physical therapy and learning (or re-learning) different skills, exercises, and movements. In fact, feedback can be absolutely necessary when learning a skill, especially if the individual has sensory or perceptual impairments. However, too much feedback and verbal bombardment can interfere with the normal internal processes of motor learning and skill acquisition.

Don’t throw the baby out with the bathwater. Verbal feedback and instruction is important and still can be utilized…just don’t talk too much!

via Luke Pedersen, PT, DPT

Reference

Textbook: Motor Learning and Control: Concepts and Application By Richard A. Magill



Want an approach that enhances your existing evaluation and treatment? No commercial model gives you THE answer. You need an approach that blends the modern with the old school. Live cases, webinars, lectures, Q&A, hundreds of techniques and more! Check out Modern Manual Therapy!

Keeping it Eclectic...





The forward lunge is a common exercise in both home fitness routines as well as with personal trainers and physical therapist to increase the load and capacity of the lower extremity during resistive training.  While the forward lunge is very common, the biomechanics of how it is performed can vary greatly.  These changes may affect how much joint stress the kneecap undergoes. Recently in the Journal of Orthopedic and Sports Therapy, a research article (1) was published regarding these alterations and how they affect the stress on the knee.  The article addressed both the trunk and lower leg position and how they affect stresses at the knee during the forward lunge exercise.