Modern Manual Therapy Blog - Manual Therapy, Videos, Neurodynamics, Podcasts, Research Reviews: logical fallacy
Showing posts with label logical fallacy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label logical fallacy. Show all posts
5 Types of Fallacies You Should Be Aware Of Part 2 - themanualtherapist.com


Last week, the topic of logical fallacies was introduced with 5 common errors that occur with clinical reasoning and deductive thinking.

This week, 5 more fallacies are presented that you will often see writers or readers intentionally or unintentionally perform with citing research.

5 Types of Fallacies to be Aware of by Cameron Faller


👉Begging the Question - This fallacy occurs when an argument's premises assume the truth instead of supporting it. This in turn creates circular reasoning as the argument is used to support the conclusion.

👉Correlation/Causation - This is one of the most common fallacies noted in randomized controlled trials. Just because something is highly correlated, doesn't mean that one causes the other. If this were the case, then one could argue that when Nicolas Cage stars in a film causes more people to drown in pools. (https://www.statsmedic.com/correlation-does-not-mean-causation)

👉Anecdotal Evidence - In place of highly driven evidence, this fallacy replaces a person's experience or one new piece of evidence as superior.

👉Middle Ground Fallacy - This fallacy assumes a compromise between two statements is always true. This ignores the fact that one of the statements could be completely true or false.

👉Burden of Proof - This occurs when someone renders a statement as true and will state it's true unless proven otherwise. For a point to be true, evidence would need to be able to support it.

👬Know someone who might find this helpful? Tag or share!

“The Devil is in the Details” 

Learn more online - new online discussion group included!


Want an approach that enhances your existing evaluation and treatment? No commercial model gives you THE answer. You need an approach that blends the modern with the old school. 
  • NEW - Online Discussion Group
  • Live cases
  • webinars
  • lecture
  • Live Q&A
  • over 600 videos - hundreds of techniques and more! 
  • Check out MMT Insiders
Keeping it Eclectic...

5 Types of Fallacies You Should Be Aware Of Part 1 - themanualtherapist.com


Detecting errors in reasoning can set you up for a better understanding of how to interpret scientific data. Many writers, willingly or unintentionally, report claims with logically incorrect reasoning that undermines the validity of their argument.

5 Types of Fallacies to be Aware of Part II by Cameron Faller


Being able to detect these logical fallacies helps you speculate on the factual data aiding in clinical decision making.

👉Strawman - This fallacy occurs when someone tries to oversimplify or misinterprets a statement to make it easier to attack.

👉Bandwagon - It may seem easy to follow the crowd when discussing certain topics, but just because the majority believes a proposition is true, doesn’t necessarily mean it’s true.

👉Appeal to Authority - This occurs when relying heavily on the opinion of someone you look up to or is well known. Just because someone in a position of power believes something to be true, doesn't make it true.

👉False Dilemma - Most topics exist on a spectrum allowing a lot of gray area to be explored. By presenting these complex issues into a “this” or “that” tries to condense the topic into two mutually exclusive options.

👉Hasty Generalization - Drawing widespread conclusions based on a small sample of evidence leads to this fallacy. This happens quite often in the literature when the researchers utilized a small subset of the general population.

The point of understanding these fallacies is to not attack others that have wrongfully mistaken these errors for valid arguments, but more so for you to critically appraise these arguments when deriving conclusions.

👬Know someone who might find this helpful? Tag or share!


“The Devil is in the Details” 

Want to learn in person? Attend a #manualtherapyparty! Check out our course calendar below!

Learn more online - new online discussion group included!


Want an approach that enhances your existing evaluation and treatment? No commercial model gives you THE answer. You need an approach that blends the modern with the old school. 
  • NEW - Online Discussion Group
  • Live cases
  • webinars
  • lecture
  • Live Q&A
  • over 600 videos - hundreds of techniques and more! 
  • Check out MMT Insiders
Keeping it Eclectic...

Five Days of Fallacies: Week 1 here, Week 2 here, Week 3 here, Week 4 here. I have discussed  some common mistakes we humans make in reasoning, in the hope that you can 1) Understand what they are 2) Recognize them when others speak 3) Recognize them when you think this way 4) Attempt to correct your thinking on old, current and future ideas.
The Fallacist's Fallacy (I like saying that) refers to an argument being refuted, simply because it uses a fallicious approach, not because the content is false. For example: "These old-school classic basketball shoes always hold up better." (an appeal to antiquity). The argument commits a fallacy (they are old = they are better), but perhaps they are constructed with more craftsmanship or durable supplies, so the content may still be true. (*are we to assume more craftsmanship and better supplies make a better B-Ball shoe?!  Oh my, don't let me make assumptions here!)
The Gambler's Fallacy is also a nice one to be aware of.(unrelated to the one above, but I'll put it in here) It involves making assumptions about future events, based on past events. The classic example is a coin toss or roulette wheel. You heavily weight the previous outcomes when making a prediction of the next coin flip or wheel turn. Ex: If you toss 5 heads in a row, the next toss will likely be tails right? Well, sorry, it's still 50/50 each time. Same with roulette. Just because black or red or the number 16 has come up recently does not influence this turn of the wheel. So watch out for the influence of prior events in your predictions of how the current or future events should/could go.
"You should not concern yourself with this semantic psychological bias stuff, there are more important topics in Physical Therapy to discuss, like Medicare Caps and Direct Access." Perhaps. However, that statement is a Fallacy of Relative Privation, or There's-bigger-fish-to-fry argument. Just because there are bigger issues, does not discount this topic series :)
Human bias is such an endlessly fascinating topic. Being drawn to these quirks in thinking also draws one towards research. Now, research may seem nerdy and full of decimal points and head-splitting math and charts, but it is also the only tool which we have to combat our biases.
Research is not perfect, but without it, we live the lives in the reality we choose, not necessarily the reality of the truth.
I'll end this with a Thought-Terminating Cliche Fallacy. Where your retort to a statement is a cliche, instead of a statement, thereby stopping the discussion. "Welp, it is what it is..." *turns, walks away*
If you liked this sort of stuff, please go to the Wikipedia and look up more.  Hope you enjoyed this series.
Cheers
-Matt Dancigers, DPT




Interested in live cases where I apply this approach and integrate it with pain science, manual therapy, repeated motions, IASTM, with emphasis on patient education? Check out Modern Manual Therapy!

Keeping it Eclectic...







Image Credit
Five Days of Fallacies: Day 1 here, Day 2 here, Day 3 here. I am discussing some common mistakes we humans make in reasoning, in the hope that you can 1) Understand what they are 2) Recognize them when others speak 3) Recognize them when you think this way 4) Attempt to correct your thinking on old, current and future ideas.
The Circular Argument, or Begging the Question. "Fascia is a tissue in the body that holds one's emotions. I know this because the research I did indicates that releasing fascia results in released emotions. Therefore, fascia holds our emotions."  In my opinion, these fallacies are very hard to understand and uncover in conversation. In circular arguments the conclusion of the statement is stated up front, and any statement after that simply restates the presumed conclusion.

Five Days of Fallacies:Week 1 here, Week 2 here. I am discussing some common mistakes we humans make in reasoning, in the hope that you can 1) Understand what they are 2) Recognize them when others speak 3) Recognize them when you think this way 4) Attempt to correct your thinking on old, current and future ideas.
Irrelevant Appeals are seen often when someone is trying to persuade you. This can be during an argument, debate, casual discussion, sales pitch, etc. The irrelevance is to the point at hand, it may seem like an important retort, however, it has no bearing on the facts. Some examples:

Five Days of Fallacies: Week 1 here, Week 3 here. I am discussing some common mistakes we humans make in reasoning, in the hope that you can 1) Understand what they are 2) Recognize them when others speak 3) Recognize them when you think this way 4) Attempt to correct your thinking on old, current and future ideas.
The Complex Question Fallacy is in the family of Fallacies of Presumption. It makes assumptions, thereby defining the conversation and the result of the outcome, when asking a question.
An easy example of this is seen here: "When are you going to admit that you lied?" You cannot say "Right now" because that is an admittance of lying. If you say "Never!" you uphold the assumption that you lied, and that you are just not admitting it. Lose lose.
How does this show up in the clinic?Often from patients who are unknowingly setting you up. "How long does this sort of disabling back pain last?" Well if you answer this question quickly, you are affirming the disabling nature of the pain, whether you think you are or not. Even if you said "oh, most people have resumed their normal activities by 4 weeks" thinking that you have put a positive prognosis on the issue, you missed the opportunity to discuss that big fat qualifier in the statement... "disabling." The patient's perspective should be addressed and concerns explored. Perhaps there is more you could gain from having them explain the disability-ness of their situation.
How does the Complex Question show up elsewhere? Oh man! Look at your continuing education pamphlets and the sales statements from the Physio Gurus out there. "How much better did you feel because of my maneuver?"  Oh! This statement has TWO! The presumption of feeling better can be affirmed with any answer AND we can affirm the presumption that the "getting better" was because of the maneuver. Even if they say "a little better" this solidifies, in the mind of the audience or patient, etc, that the result was "because of the maneuver." (There is an out in this example, the individual could say "I felt no better" but this statement is also heavily laden with Anchoring and Priming.)
Misleading Vividness, or Anecdotal Fallacy can mislead in a similar way, in that the argument presumes widespread prevalence or importance, based off a single event. A person may describe an event or treatment or maneuver in such detail, that it seemingly has more gravitas. Example: "I treated her with global exercise." vs "I started with the patient in side-lying, rotated the shoulder back 45 degrees and applied a rotational force through both the hips and the shoulder girdle in opposing directions. An audible pop was heard and felt stimulating mechanoreceptors at the joint and down regulating ion channels of the nociceptors in the area." The detail enhances the event. And, as we know from blinded research, isolated hands on manipulative therapy is no better than general exercise for many conditions.
The above works off a cognitive bias called Recall Bias, where things that are easier to recall seem more frequent and therefor more important. Think of being killed by the Flu vs killed in a plane crash. We are often more fearful of the plane crash because of the misleading vividness and recall bias. In this case, however, the Flu is statistically much more likely to affect you or your family. Perhaps in the above example, the times when you got a good 'pop' are more vivid to you than the times a patient got better with traditional therapeutic exercise, thereby increasing your impression of the technique. 
So, what to do about these? Listen. Slow down, stop if you have to. Go over the statement's words and locate what is actually being asked or stated. This is how you get around all the Fallacies of Presumption. Does the argument or statement assume anything? If so, can that assumption be agreed upon? In presuming a concept are you altering the context of your answer? Does this one event, as salient as it is, represent a majority of events.
*Note: we certainly make presumptions during conversation. They are often correct and are needed for the communications to commence.For example, we assume we are using the same meaning of words when we communicate. (this is not always the case!) Just watch out for these sneaky complex questions and anecdotes.
So, think about these questions. "It is experience bounced off the wall of thought and thrown into the sea of reflection that ultimately returns the reward of expertise."  
Stay tuned next week for more Fallacies!...
-Matt Dancigers, DPT



Interested in live cases where I apply this approach and integrate it with pain science, manual therapy, repeated motions, IASTM, with emphasis on patient education? Check out Modern Manual Therapy!

Keeping it Eclectic...